For Business

Lucy and Sophie - Shareholder Case Study 2

Lucy and Sophie ran a PR company and they never got around to putting a shareholder agreement in place. When relations between them became irreparable their only option was to wind up the company.

Case Study

Lucy and Sophie ran a PR company. They had worked together in a larger company previously and 12 years ago they decided to break away and set up on their own. At the beginning things were tight and they put all their money into getting the business up and running. They knew about shareholders agreements, but decided not to spend the money on solicitors straight away. They felt that they would be ok initially and that they would put a shareholder agreement in place in the second year once they knew that the business was going to be a success.

Things got busy and they never got around to seeing the solicitor about the shareholder agreement.

The business grew nicely and produced Lucy and Sophie with a nice income. They were both equal shareholders and directors.

However, over time relations between Lucy and Sophie started to deteriorate. There was no single catalyst, but they disagreed regularly with the way in which they both saw the business developing and the types of clients that they should target. Eventually, things got so bad that they could not discuss anything without arguing. This had a detrimental effect on the business. It was no longer growing. Strategic decisions were not being taken and profits were falling. Clients sensed the problems and were leaving and employees felt that they were caught in the middle of the feuding owners and were either unhappy and therefore less productive or they left.

Without a shareholder agreement in place detailing how the dispute should be settled, it was down to Lucy and Sophie to resolve their differences. But they could not.

Their only option, therefore, was to wind up the company, if they could agree on this course of action, or apply to the court for an order that the company is wound up, which would be an expensive process with no guarantee that the court would grant such an order.

A shareholder agreement could have included a detailed process for resolving disputes or remedying the situation if they really could not. The dispute resolution procedures can include requiring mediation, where a third party intervenes and attempts to encourage both parties to work through their issues, or it could allow one party to serve notice on the other offering to buy the other’s shares or sell their own shares at a single fixed price. This would ensure that there is a prescriptive procedure allowing for the dispute to be resolved one way or another and for the company to continue trading with the least disruption possible

Seek expert legal advice

The specialist lawyers at Neves have extensive experience in assisting clients with putting a shareholder agreement in place. Contact our Company Commercial team on 0330 0945 500, email info@nevesllp.co.uk or complete our Contact Form and we’ll get back to you.

Lucy and Sophie - Shareholder Case Study 2

Need a shareholder agreement?

CONTACT US TODAY

5/5 Star review

Powered by

Neves recently undertook our conveyancing and did an excellent job; the communication from Charlene Shillingford and her team throughout the whole process was top notch - I don’t recall being kept so up to date during the selling and buying of a house before. Queries were handled quickly and with the minimum of fuss, even when ‘the other side’ were being ‘difficult’. I’ve no reservation in recommending Neves. My heartfelt thanks to Charlene and the conveyancing team for their diligence and care during what can be a fraught time.

From Gareth Davies a month ago.

5/5 Star review

Powered by

Determined is the first word springing to mind when sharing my experience with Neeves Solicitors LLP. Despite the hurdles, despite the delays, Jackie and Charlene continued to press on to produce results, with continuous updates throughout our request no matter how trivial. I am more than happy with the services they were able to provide and would recommend this firm to family and friends.

From Marcus Gardner a month ago.

5/5 Star review

Powered by

Beth Woodward, I wanted to say thank you for supporting me on my recent divorce. Faced with one of the most aggressive and unpleasant legal firms in London, you led me through both the family and financial divorce courts and more than achieved every one of my goals for the divorce. Most importantly, I have equal time parenting with my two girls and a really fair settlement so I can support them financially, both not even remotely offered by the other side. You listened and supported me when I really went for it, kept me sane through the FDR and court visits and also gave me the tough messages when I need to hear it. Thank you, I can’t quite explain how we did it, but we did 😊 😊 😊 😊

From Chris 2 months ago.

5/5 Star review

Powered by

Emily has supported me through a divorce with excellent advice and guidance at every stage. All issues and options were explained clearly and fully. Possible outcomes were fully outlined to me throughout the process. Emily's professionalism has been of the highest standard. The kind and understanding manner in which Emily has supported me at all stages of the process is something that I am extremely grateful for. I literally felt the pressure shift from my shoulders. This is why I give 5 stars for the assistance I received.

From L L 3 months ago.

5/5 Star review

Powered by

I left this review for a few months as I wanted to let everything settle down and get my own head space back. On behalf of myself and my family, I just wanted to express our heart felt thanks to Beth for navigating us through a difficult divorce and parenting matters. Perhaps a little unconventional because as a dad, my teenage daughter wanted to remain living with me and yet I was also the main earner. We trusted Beth to give us timely, clear and succinct advice, help challenge tactics from the other side and understand the needs of my daughter whilst protecting my independent assets. We are so pleased with the outcome of the issues and all of the initial objectives were met. Beth, the whole of my family (children and grandchildren too) cannot thank you and your team enough. We have our home and family life back, fun and normality have resumed and a lunatic puppy is in place to help us heal and grow. Having trust in professional people is crucial at such a difficult time in life, and feeling that you have a solicitor of such high calibre took some pressure away when it was hard to deal with everything else. There were times that I felt Beth carried me through the process and times where I almost asked you to make decisions for me. It is a messy process, people get hurt and tears flow but thank you for your professionalism and understanding.

From J S 5 months ago.